Just a Child or Two

by Chris
May 25th, 2005 11:59 pm

Let’s get hypothetical. Let’s take a middle school special education teacher who teaches life skills to children with Down’s Syndrome, Fragile X and severe Autism. Let’s assume that this teacher spends the majority of her work day teaching her students, well, life skills. These are skills that will enable those children to live the most productive lives possible, enabling them to function and contribute to society, and ease the burden of care on their families as they mature and become adults.

Let’s just take one small hypothetical example; a middle school life skills teacher who focuses a large number of her reading lessons on survival words and phrases such as “Fire Exit”, “Caution”, “Stop”, “No Trespassing”, “Do Not Cross”, “Poison”, “Do Not Touch” and “Danger - High Voltage”. Some other lessons would probably involve reading and executing simple cooking recipes and other similar exercises. If you understand the disabilities involved, just a little, you probably understand why this sort of thing would be very important.

Let’s take this example a little further. Under the No Child Left Behind law, all public school teachers must prove themselves to be highly qualified. This generally involves plunking down $86, and taking something called a Praxis Exam. In order for a life skills teacher to teach severely learning disabled children, above the seventh grade, in any type of language arts, he or she must prove themselves highly qualified to do so, by taking the appropriate Praxis Examination.

Now, you would probably imagine that in order to gain a position with a title like “life skills teacher”, that an individual would have had to have achieve a masters degree in special education. You can probably safely assume that in achieving that degree, they would have taken a number of classes with brutal titles such as “Teaching Survival Skills to the Severely Disabled”. You can probably safely assume that they had to do a significant amount of documented work in the field in order to fulfill their educational requirements.

Let’s take this example to its reasonable conclusion. When our veteran life skills teacher sits down to take her Praxis Exam, in order to become highly qualified to teach middle school life skills students and keep her job, you would probably assume that the majority of the language arts portion of that test would not involve comprehensive knowledge of Shakespeare’s works. You would be very wrong. Dead wrong, as a matter of fact.

How ’bout them apples?

5 Responses to “Just a Child or Two”

  1. pencopal Says:

    Wow. That’s completely ridiculous. The test should be tailored to the subject matter you teach. I can’t believe that.

  2. Ruth Says:

    I’m working toward an M.A. in speech-language pathology, and will have to take the Praxis exam to be certified to work in the schools. I just found out that this will involve passing sections of the test that involve knowledge of science, math, history, etc. Now, I’m personally not tremendously worried about this, but it does seem fairly ridiculous that after passing all of the necessary academic AND clinical coursework required for this program, and the comprehensive examinations required by Temple (brutally hard essay-format questions on any possible speech-language topic) I also need to know this information, when I am NOT ever going to be required to teach this to the children I serve. I agree, it’s absolutely ridiculous.

  3. Chris Says:

    The thing I want to try to highlight in the future is the fact that veteran special education teachers, who have spent years teaching kids with specific developmental and learning disabilities, are being required to take exams which test knowledge they have never, and will never, need. My Shakespeare example was accurate and really is the height of silliness. How is that applicable to teaching a 14 year old boy or girl with Down’s syndrome? Why on earth would a person’s job depend on knowledge they do not need?

    Good luck on your tests Ruth. Don’t I owe you a beer or two?

  4. Ruth Says:

    Yep, you do! I’ve been so swamped I haven’t been able to claim them. The next time I’m free would be next Friday night (june 3) - are you around then? And as the parent of two special ed kids, I agree with the point of your post - a life skills teacher should NOT have to pass a test with information about Shakespeare, it is ridiculous.

  5. Chris Says:

    June 3 is fine.

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.


Bad Behavior has blocked 1506 access attempts in the last 7 days.